One expert blockchain attorney has simple advice for blockchain companies currently navigating regulatory uncertainty.
Though the technology has been up for discussion for years, laws arenât very clear right now with a tangle of regulatory bodies that all might, or might not, have some power over different aspects of the technology. Bitcoin has seen some progress in that respect, but with other projects like ethereum now emerging, an entirely new ecosystem of use cases is springing up.
Much of the conversation during the CoinDeskâs Consensus 2017Â legal workshop centered on this confusing state of affairs.
Harvard Berkman Center fellow and special counsel at Cooley LLP Patrick Murck argued that, while this regulatory uncertainty might cause problems for businesses, itâs actually better that regulators are so far taking a hands-off approach to blockchain companies and letting the ecosystem develop itâs own system for weeding out bad actors.
In the meantime, though, he had some advice:
âAs long as youâre not stupid or have ill-intent, most of the time youâre going to be fine. Itâs amazing how common-sensical this could be. Donât be stupid. Donât have ill-intent.â
Another trend discussed during the panel, one that very much related to this uncertainty, was the growing spread of initial coin offerings (ICOs).
The potential for ICOs (or token sales) was one of the more prominent themes at CoinDeskâs Consensus 2017 conference at large, and it popped up again and again during the dayâs three-hour legal session.
Advocates argued that the concept is fueling a new, more democratic way of funding businesses inspired by cryptocurrency, but it could also have its downsides amid the recent hype cycle.
âWhat we have now is the term âICOsâ. I donât know who started that, but they should be reprimanded for it,â Perkins Coie partner Dax Hansen joked, adding that âtoken saleâ is a term with better regulatory implications. Though, as for the concept itself, he said that many entrepreneurs are using the funding model in legitimate and promising ways.
And, itâs indeed an exploding market right now. Davis Polk associate Reuben Grinberg claimed that over half of venture spending in the space now comes from ICOs, rather than older, arguably less democratic, methods of raising money.
A panelist from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) noted that this form of funding is exploding, doubling just in the last few weeks.
âI think youâre right that itâs starting to reach a level where regulators will take a look at it. Where that goes, I donât know,â he added.
But even if regulators have held back so far, other legal experts think that more regulatory action could be around the corner. Grinberg, for one, argued that catastrophe might ultimately be what piques the action of regulators.
He said:
âWhen everyoneâs making money, then everyoneâs happy, but when everyoneâs losing money and their houses â which has happened in the past â then youâre going to start to see regulatory actions.â
Correction: The article has been revised to clarify Hansenâs comments.
Image via Alyssa Hertig for CoinDesk